All-America
ABCA Rawlings All-America
1971
- Dale Herbert — First Baseman
1982
- Tom Bilski — Third Team, Designated Hitter
2014
- Kyle Chontos — Second Team, First Baseman
2016
- Mark Zimmerman — Third Team, Utility Player
2018
- Dudley Taw — Second Team, Outfielder
2019
- Danny Cody — Second Team, Starting Pitcher
2022
- Luke Vonderhaar — Third Team, First Baseman
- Alex Ludwick — Third Team, Shortstop
2023
- Alexis Castillo — Fourth Team, Designated Hitter
d3baseball.com All-America
2013
- Brendan Toughey — Honorable Mention, Outfielder
2014
- Kyle Chontos — Honorable Mention, First Baseman
2019
- Danny Cody — Fourth Team, Starting Pitcher
2022
- Luke Vonderhaar — Fourth Team, First Baseman
2023
- Alexis Castillo — Fourth Team, Designated Hitter
2025
- Brit Kostura — Fifth Team, Pitcher