The Baldwin Wallace University baseball team has earned a bid to the NCAA Division III playoffs nine times. BW’s first bid came in 1985, following its first-place finish in the Ohio Athletic Conference championship tournament. The Yellow Jackets returned to the playoffs three more times over the next six seasons.
In 2014 the Yellow Jackets swept through the Mid-Atlantic regional tournament, claiming their first regional championship and their first trip to the Division III College World Series. The Jackets edged eventual runner-up Emory University 5–4 in the opening round of the series before their record-setting postseason run finally came to an end. They repeated their regional sweep in 2022, this time including a two-game trip through the new Super Regionals, to punch their second ticket to the College World Series
1985
Midwest Regional, University of Wisconsin–Oshkosh, Oshkosh, Wis.
- Luther College 6 vs. St. Olaf College 1
- University of Wisconsin–Oshkosh 10 vs. Baldwin-Wallace College 2
- Luther 2 vs. Wisconsin-Oshkosh 1
- Baldwin-Wallace 6 vs. St. Olaf 3
- Wisconsin-Oshkosh 5 vs. Baldwin-Wallace 3
- Wisconsin-Oshkosh 12 vs. Luther 2
- Wisconsin-Oshkosh 12 vs. Luther 4
1986
Mideast Regional, Ohio State University, Columbus, Ohio
- Baldwin-Wallace College 5 vs. North Central College 4
- MacMurray College 6 vs. College of Wooster 5
- Marietta College 9 vs. Ohio Wesleyan University 7
- Wooster 10 vs. Ohio Wesleyan 7
- North Central 12 vs. Marietta 6
- MacMurray 8 vs. Baldwin-Wallace 5
- Marietta 8 vs. Baldwin-Wallace 4
- North Central 8 vs. Wooster 0
- Marietta 15 vs. MacMurray 8
- North Central 12 vs. MacMurray 4
- Marietta 13 vs. North Central 11
1988
Mideast Regional, Marietta College, Marietta, Ohio
- Elmhurst College 1 vs. College of Wooster 0
- Baldwin-Wallace College 8 vs. Elizabethtown College 4
- Marietta College 9 vs. North Park College 5
- Wooster 12 vs. Elizabethtown 6
- North Park 13 vs. Elmhurst 3
- Marietta 12 vs. Baldwin-Wallace 8
- Elmhurst 12 vs. Baldwin-Wallace 6
- North Park 13 vs. Wooster 7
- Marietta 7 vs. Elmhurst 2
- Marietta 4 vs. North Park 0
1991
Mideast Regional, Marietta College, Marietta, Ohio
- College of Wooster 14 vs. Baldwin-Wallace College 13
- Marietta College 13 vs. Ferrum College 4
- Ferrum 13 vs. Baldwin-Wallace 3
- Marietta 11 vs. Wooster 3
- Ferrum 6 vs. Wooster 4
- Marietta 9 vs. Ferrum 6
2014
Mid-Atlantic Regional, Misericordia University, Moosic, Pa.
- Baldwin Wallace University 8 vs. Misericordia University 4
- Haverford College 3 vs. Moravian College 1
- Susquehanna University 5 vs. Keystone College 3
- Rowan University 7 vs. Wesleyan University 2
- Misericordia 4 vs. Moravian 3
- Wesleyan 6 vs. Keystone 0
- Baldwin Wallace 10 vs. Haverford 2
- Susquehanna 5 vs. Rowan 4
- Wesleyan 6 vs. Haverford 3
- Misericordia 1 vs. Rowan 0
- Baldwin Wallace 4 vs. Susquehanna 1
- Wesleyan 6 vs. Misericordia 1
- Wesleyan 4 vs. Susquehanna 3
- Baldwin Wallace 9 vs. Wesleyan 7
College World Series, Fox Cities Stadium, Appleton, Wis.
- University of St. Thomas 10 vs. Linfield College 0
- Baldwin Wallace University 5 vs. Emory University 4
- SUNY Cortland 4 vs. Salisbury University 3
- University of Wisconsin–Whitewater 8 vs. University of Southern Maine 1
- Emory 8 vs. Linfield 5
- Southern Maine 6 vs. Salisbury 3
- St. Thomas 5 vs. Baldwin Wallace 4
- Wisconsin-Whitewater 9 vs. Cortland 6
- Southern Maine 11 vs. Baldwin Wallace 5
- Emory 9 vs. Cortland 7
- Wisconsin-Whitewater 10 vs. St. Thomas 4
- Emory 15 vs. Southern Maine 3
- Emory 10 vs. St. Thomas 7
- Wisconsin-Whitewater 7 vs. Emory 0
2015
New York Regional, SUNY Cortland, Auburn, N.Y.
- Amherst College 7 vs. SUNY Oswego 5
- SUNY Cortland 6 vs. Oberlin College 4
- Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute 2 vs. Keystone College 0
- SUNY Old Westbury 7 vs. Baldwin Wallace University 5
- Oberlin 7 vs. Oswego 2
- Keystone 4 vs. Baldwin Wallace 2
- Cortland 7 vs. Amherst 5
- RPI 12 vs. Old Westbury 2
- Keystone 7 vs. Amherst 2
- Oberlin 9 vs. Old Westbury 3
- Cortland 7 vs. RPI 5
- Oberlin 5 vs. Keystone 4
- RPI 5 vs. Oberlin 4
- Cortland 7 vs. RPI 0
2018
New York Regional, SUNY Cortland, Auburn, N.Y.
- Swarthmore College 11 vs. Baldwin Wallace University 6
- SUNY Cortland 5 vs. Westfield State University 4 (10 inn.)
- University of Southern Maine 3 vs. Amherst College 2
- Salisbury University 3 vs. St. Joseph’s College Long Island 2 (10 inn.)
- Baldwin Wallace 3 vs. Westfield State 2
- St. Joseph’s 2 vs. Amherst 1
- Swarthmore 3 vs. Cortland 2
- Southern Maine 1 vs. Salisbury 0
- Cortland 9 vs. St. Joseph’s 7
- Baldwin Wallace 14 vs. Salisbury 3
- Swarthmore 9 vs. Southern Maine 6
- Cortland 10 vs. Baldwin Wallace 9 (11 inn.)
- Southern Maine 12 vs. Cortland 10 (10 inn.)
- Swarthmore 9 vs. Southern Maine 3
2019
Central Regional, Concordia University Chicago, River Forest, Ill.
- Concordia University Chicago 2 vs. Buena Vista University 0
- Baldwin Wallace University 5 vs. St. John’s University 4 (10 inn.)
- Buena Vista 7 vs. St. John’s 3
- Baldwin Wallace 10 vs. Concordia Chicago 8
- Concordia Chicago 11 vs. Buena Vista 5
- Concordia Chicago 14 vs. Baldwin Wallace 13 (10 inn.)
- Concordia Chicago 5 vs. Baldwin Wallace 3
2022
Brockport Regional, SUNY Brockport, Brockport, N.Y.
- #4 Johnson & Wales University 6 vs. #1 Wheaton College 3
- #2 Baldwin Wallace University 4 vs. #3 SUNY Brockport 3
- Wheaton 6 vs. Brockport 2
- Baldwin Wallace 13 vs. Johnson & Wales 4
- Wheaton 9 vs. Johnson & Wales 3
- Baldwin Wallace 11 vs. Wheaton 6
Super Regional, Endicott College, Beverly, Mass.
- Baldwin Wallace University 4 vs. Endicott College 2
- Baldwin Wallace 7 vs. Endicott 4
College World Series, Veterans Memorial Stadium, Cedar Rapids, Iowa
- #1 Marietta College 7 vs. #8 Catholic University 0
- #4 Salisbury University 8 vs. #5 University of Wisconsin–Stevens Point 2
- #2 Eastern Connecticut State University 10 vs. #7 Baldwin Wallace University 3
- #3 LaGrange College 12 vs. #6 Trinity University 0
- Wisconsin–Stevens Point 12 vs. Catholic 8
- Salisbury 7 vs. Marietta 5
- Trinity 6 vs. Baldwin Wallace 5
- Eastern Connecticut 4 vs. LaGrange 3
- Wisconsin–Stevens Point 6 vs. Marietta 4
- LaGrange 14 vs. Trinity 3
- Salisbury 5 vs. Wisconsin–Stevens Point 2
- Eastern Connecticut 8 vs. LaGrange 1
- Eastern Connecticut 11 vs. Salisbury 6
- Eastern Connecticut 3 vs. Salisbury 2