All–Mideast Region
1971
- Dale Herbert — First Baseman
1973
- Dale Herbert — First Baseman
1982
- Tom Bilski — First Team, Designated Hitter
1983
- Jeff Andrews — Second Team, First Baseman
1984
- Tom Bilski — First Team, Designated Hitter
- Jim Magazine — Honorable Mention, Second Baseman
1985
- Jim Stefanik — First Team, Outfielder
- Jim Magazine — Honorable Mention, Second Baseman
1986
- Dean Obrock — Second Team, Pitcher
- Erik Young — Second Team, Outfielder
- Jim Magazine — Honorable Mention, Second Baseman
1987
- Erik Young — First Team, Outfielder
1988
- Erik Young — First Team, Outfielder
- Bernie Bonhotel — Honorable Mention, Pitcher
- Paul Farrah — Honorable Mention, Designated Hitter
1989
- Erik Young — Second Team, Outfielder
- Phil Stringer — Honorable Mention, Outfielder
1990
- Phil Stringer — First Team, Designated Hitter
- Brian Kosar — Second Team, Pitcher
- Dan DeVoe — Second Team, Third Baseman
- Andy Palmer — Honorable Mention, First Baseman
- Bryan Dudash — Honorable Mention, Outfielder
1991
- Joey Dallas — Second Team, Catcher
- Bob Kelley — Honorable Mention, Designated Hitter
1992
- Joey Dallas — Second Team, Catcher
- Dave Snyder — Honorable Mention, Second Baseman
- Mark Massey — Honorable Mention, Outfielder
1993
- Phil Lopez — Honorable Mention, Catcher
- Greg Andrego — Honorable Mention, Second Baseman
1994
- Phil Lopez — Honorable Mention, Catcher
1995
- Joel Nichols — Second Team, Catcher
1996
- Joel Nichols — Second Team, Catcher
- Steve Murphy — Honorable Mention, Second Baseman
1998
- Brian Rudloff — Second Team, Pitcher
2001
- Jim Leffler — First Team, Shortstop
2002
- Pat Shannon — Second Team, First Baseman
- Jim Leffler — Second Team, Shortstop
- Pete Rowe — Honorable Mention, Outfielder
2003
- Pat Shannon — Second Team, First Baseman
- Jim Leffler — Honorable Mention, Shortstop
2004
- Mike Farrell — Second Team, Designated Hitter
- Dale Koler — Third Team, Pitcher
- Mike Turchan — Third Team, Utility Player
2005
- Mike Turchan — Second Team, Utility Player
2006
- Dan Melito — Second Team, Outfielder
2009
- Riley Kreisher — Second Team, First Baseman
- Cody Kidd — Second Team, Outfielder
2012
- Pat Havens — Third Team, Pitcher
2013
- Brendan Toughey — First Team, Outfielder
2014
- Kyle Chontos — First Team, First Baseman
- Mark Zimmerman — Second Team, Second Baseman
- Hunter Handel — Second Team, Designated Hitter
2015
- Mark Zimmerman — First Team, Utility Player
- Cole Nieto — Second Team, Second Baseman
2016
- Mark Zimmerman — First Team, Mideast Region Player of the Year, Utility Player
- Evan Lovick — Second Team, Pitcher
2017
- Evan Lovick — Second Team, Pitcher
2018
- Dudley Taw — First Team, Outfielder
- Alex Marcum — Second Team, Outfielder
- Evan Lovick — Third Team, Pitcher
- Danny Cody — Third Team, Pitcher
2019
- Danny Cody — First Team, Mideast Region Pitcher of the Year
2021
- Alex Ludwick — Second Team, Shortstop
- Dudley Taw — Second Team, Outfielder
