Outstanding Freshman
- 1970 — Dale Herbert, First Baseman
- 1973 — Harold Myers, Pitcher
- 1974 — Pat George, Pitcher
- 1976 — Joe Surniak, Catcher
- 1977 — Jeff McAllester, Second Baseman
- 1978 — Steve Dockman, Pitcher
- 1981 — Pat Campbell, Outfielder
- 1982 — Jeff Doorey, Pitcher
- 1983 — Dean Obrock, Pitcher
- 1984 — Marty Kelley, Catcher
- 1985 — John DiDonato, Catcher
- 1986 — Erik Young, Outfielder
- 1987 — Don Boynar, Shortstop
- 1988 — Colin Johnson, Catcher
- 1989 — Dave Snyder, Second Baseman
- 1990 — Andy Robinson, Pitcher
- 1991 — Chris Matejcik, Shortstop
- 1992 — Mike Laub, Pitcher
- 1993 — Steve Murphy, Third Baseman
- 1994 — Aaron Holby, Outfielder
- 1995 — Max Newill, Pitcher
- 1996 — Tim Obergefell, Outfielder
- 1997 — Tony Jurcsisn, Outfielder
- 1998 — Marty Thompson, Pitcher
- 2000 — Jim Leffler, Shortstop
- 2001 — Dale Koler, Pitcher
- 2002 — Mike Turchan, Second Baseman and Pitcher
- 2003 — Dan Melito, Outfielder
- 2004 — Nick Quarando, Third Baseman
- 2005 — Shaun Slater, Outfielder
- 2006 — Cody Kidd, Outfielder
- 2007 — Jim Palko, Pitcher
- 2008 — Ben Stoper, Outfielder
- 2009 — Anthony Longhitano, Shortstop
- 2010 — Nolan Neuschaefer, Outfielder
- 2011 — Cory Waite, Pitcher
- 2012 — Kyle Chontos, First Baseman
- 2013 — Mark Zimmerman, Second Baseman
- 2014 — Logan Heffernan, Pitcher
- 2015 — Evan Lovick, Pitcher
- 2016 — Philip Wells, Outfielder
- 2017 — Jacob Bonner, Third Baseman
- 2018 — Alex Ludwig, Shortstop
- 2019 — Garrett Miller, Pitcher
