Putouts
Most Putouts, Career — 1,215 — Kyle Chontos, 2012–2015
Most Putouts, Season — 404 — Kyle Chontos, 2014
Assists
Most Assists, Career — 518 — Eric Murphy, 2012–2015
Most Assists, Season — 163 — Eric Murphy, 2015
Fielding Percentage
Catchers
Highest Fielding Percentage, Career — .988 — Ryan Nordquist, 2009–2012
Highest Fielding Percentage, Decade
- 1960s — .977 — Bernie Simmons, 1966–1969
- 1970s — .980 — Pete Sedello, 1970–1972
- 1980s — .979 — Eric Cameron, 1988–1989
- 1990s — .987 — T.J. Shalek, 1997–1999
- 2000s — .987 — Jeremy Stacy, 1999–2002
- 2010s — .988 — Ryan Nordquist, 2009–2012
Highest Fielding Percentage, Season — 1.000 — Eric Cameron, 1989; Jeremy Stacy, 2000; Pat Gallagher, 2004; Matt Bolte, 2008; and Ryan Nordquist, 2012
Infielders
Highest Fielding Percentage, Career — .994 — Riley Kreisher, 2006–2009
Highest Fielding Percentage, Decade
- 1960s — .973 — Jim Bukac, 1964–1967
- 1970s — .987 — Gus Corfman, 1967–1970
- 1980s — .985 — Jeff Andrews, 1982–1983
- 1990s — .992 — Mike Urban, 1993–1995; and Mark Stomieroski, 1997–1998
- 2000s — .994 — Riley Kreisher, 2006–2009
- 2010s — .987 — Kyle Chontos, 2012–2015; and Hunter Handel, 2013–2016
Highest Fielding Percentage, Season — 1.000 — Dick Tressel, 1968
Outfielders
Highest Fielding Percentage, Career — .993 — Chris Nealon, 2007–2010
Highest Fielding Percentage, Decade
- 1970s — .961 — Ed Pizzuto, 1975–1977
- 1980s — .971 — Pat Campbell, 1981–1984
- 1990s — .974 — Eric Ridge, 1997–1998
- 2000s — .979 — Brian Keller, 2000–2003
- 2010s — .993 — Chris Nealon, 2007–2010
Highest Fielding Percentage, Season — 1.000 — Dan D’Amore, 1971; Cliff Drobnik, 1971; Pat Campbell, 1983; Dave Rozzo, 1986; John Floriea, 1987; Chris Mineard, 1995; Ted Cowling, 2010; Nolan Neuschaefer, 2010; Brendan Toughey, 2013; Chase Knodle, 2017; and Dudley Taw, 2018
