Before the 2005 season, the Ohio Athletic Conference determined pitching champions for cumulative statistics, like strikeouts, based on statistical totals and per-game or per-inning averages. Where one of BW’s pitchers led the conference in both the statistical total and the per-game or per-inning average, the average is included in parentheses.
Wins
- 1972 — Curt Karpinski — 6
Win-Loss Record
- 1963 — Harvey Warner — 2–0
- 1965 — Bob Love — 3–0; and Tom Helwick — 2–0
- 1967 — Jack Mental — 4–0; and Jim Boynar — 2–0
- 1972 — Curt Karpinski — 6–0
- 1990 — Brian Kosar — 8–0
- 1996 — Brian Rudloff — 6–0
- 2002 — Heath Baker — 6–0
Saves
- 1999 — Charlie Schemmel — 4
- 2012 — Jon Tenley — 7
- 2014 — Brandon Cichocki — 8
Fewest Walks
- 2008 — Justin Novak — 7
- 2009 — Justin Novak — 4
Strikeouts
- 1966 — Bob Love — 83
- 1968 — Bob Love — 88 (1.43 per Inning)
- 1971 — Curt Karpinski — 1.48 per Inning
- 1976 — Pat George — 11.7 per Game
- 1983 — Scott Medvin — 13.3 per Game
- 1988 — Bernie Bonhotel — 91
- 1999 — Tony Johnson — 10.8 per Game
- 2002 — Dale Koler — 10.0 per Game
- 2004 — Dale Koler — 12.0 per Game
- 2018 — Danny Cody — 100
Earned Run Average
- 1972 — Curt Karpinski — 0.63
- 1975 — Mark Pettigrew — 1.09
- 1998 — Brian Rudloff — 1.68
