OAC All-Tournament Team
1987
1988
- Don Boynar — Shortstop
- Phil Stringer — Outfielder
1990
- Colin Johnson — Catcher
- Don Boynar — Shortstop
- Bryan Dudash — Outfielder
1991
- Bret Butler — Pitcher
- Chris Matejcik — Shortstop
- Brad Boynar — Outfielder
- Mark Massey — Outfielder
1992
- Bob Kelley — Designated Hitter
1994
- Phil Lopez — Catcher
- Aaron Holby — Outfielder
1996
- Brian Madigan — Designated Hitter
1998
2002
2014
- Logan Heffernan — Pitcher
- Brad Gugliotta — Third Baseman
- Eric Murphy — Shortstop
- Alex Green — Outfielder
- Hunter Handel — Designated Hitter
2015
- Mark Zimmerman — Third Baseman
2016
- Tom Loeffler — Pitcher
- Mark Zimmerman — Shortstop
- Cole Nieto — Outfielder
2018
- Spencer Badia — Co–Most Valuable Player, Second Baseman
- Alex Marcum — Co–Most Valuable Player, Outfielder
- Evan Lovick — Pitcher
- Chase Knodle — Outfielder
- Dudley Taw — Outfielder
2019
- Asa Adams — Catcher
- Sam Sustersic — Designated Hitter
2021
2022
- Dawson Gabe — Pitcher
- Luke Vonderhaar — First Baseman
- Ryan Guggenheim — Second Baseman
- Vincent Capolupo — Outfielder