College students have been playing baseball in Berea since the late 1880s. In the fall of 1894, students from Baldwin University and German Wallace College formed an athletic association to “further develop the growth of athletics in the two colleges, which though different in name, in feeling they are as one.”
Baldwin pitcher A.H. Wicks captained the first Baldwin Wallace baseball team through its inaugural season the following spring.
Since those early days, more than 1,000 young men have played varsity baseball for Baldwin Wallace University.
| Player | Career | Position | Games | Hometown |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dean Obrock | 1983–1986 | P | 38 | |
| Gene Obrock | 1981 | P | 7 | |
| Barney Odell | 1982–1983 | C | 12 | |
| Scot Oehlstrom | 1985–1987 | P | 30 | |
| E. L. Ohle | 1897 | 1B | ||
| Jim Ohlemacher | 1963 | 2B/SS | 15 | |
| Oliver | 1921 | SS/RF | ||
| Art Olson | 1955 | P | ||
| Mario Onesko | 1985–1986 | 1B | 18 | |
| Elwood Oring | 1931 | LF/CF | ||
| A. Ott | 1912 | C | ||
| W. Ott | 1912 | P | ||
| Dick Overla | 1957–1958 | 3B | ||
| Jose Pagan | 1970–1973 | 2B | 32 | |
| Dave Painter | 1996–1998 | 2B | 71 | Shaker Heights |
| Adam Pajakowski | 2002–2005 | C | 88 | South Bend, IN |
| Jim Palko | 2007–2009 | P | 23 | Euclid |
| Alec Palmer | 2015 | P | 4 | Oakdale, PA |
| Andy Palmer | 1987–1990 | 1B/P | 98 | |
| Matt Palumbo | 1990–1991 | P/1B | 34 | |
| George Panstares | 1991–1993 | 3B/OF | 56 | |
| Will Pantages | 2011–2013 | P | 14 | Akron |
| Tom Papp | 1956 | OF | ||
| Merlin Parent | 1927 | OF | ||
| Andrew Parker | 2021 | C/OF | 24 | Toledo |
| Stacy Parker | 1983–1985 | P | 24 | |
| Keith Parks | 1961 | P | 1 | |
| Jim Parmenter | 1960–1961 | IF | 17 | |
| Jeff Pascarella | 1990–1992 | P | 27 | |
| Chris Paterakis | 1987 | P | 7 | |
| Nick Patrone | 2015–2018 | P | 15 | Bellaire |
| Jack Patterson | 1955 | P | ||
| J. M. Patton | 1899 | |||
| Bob Payne | 1946 | P | ||
| Tony Payton | 1985–1986 | OF | 12 | |
| Brian Pelfrey | 1988–1990 | P | 19 | |
| Carl Pennington | 2021 | IF | 2 | Wadsworth |
| Kyle Pennington | 2016–2019 | 2B | 98 | Wadsworth |
| Gordon Perkins | 1969–1970 | 3B | 17 | |
| Ryan Petraitis | 2001–2004 | 3B/1B | 91 | Akron |
| Mike Petrone | 1966 | P | 5 | |
| Ryan Petrusky | 2002–2003 | P | 23 | Cuyahoga Falls |
| Dan Pettay | 1962 | OF | ||
| Mark Pettigrew | 1974–1977 | P | 50 | |
| E. J. Pfeiffer | 1909 | P | ||
| Dave Phillips | 1962–1963 | P | 9 | |
| Sam Phillips | 1962 | C | ||
| Glenn Phipps | 1997–2000 | SS/DH | 118 | Huntingtown, MD |
| Mark Pickering | 1992–1993 | OF/C | 45 | |
| Brian Pille | 2005–2007 | P | 22 | Lorain |
| Player | Career | Position | Games | Hometown |
